Spread bets and CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading spread bets and CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how spread bets and CFDs work, and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.
CFD vs Spread betting
Spread betting and CFDs are traded on margin, learn the key differences.
Call 020 7638 6996 or email newaccounts@guardianstockbrokers.com to discuss opening a trading account.
Introduction to CFDs vs Spread Betting
In the world of financial trading, CFDs and spread betting have gained immense popularity among traders looking to speculate on the direction of financial markets. Both trading approaches offer unique advantages, but they also come with distinct differences that traders must be aware of to make informed decisions and effectively manage their risk. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into their key differences, weigh their pros and cons, compare costs and charges, and help traders choose the best trading strategy based on their individual preferences and goals.
1 CFD vs Spread Betting: Understanding the Key Differences
Understanding the crucial disparities is essential for any trader, here are the key differences:
Tax Efficiency:
A standout feature of spread betting, particularly in the UK, is its exceptional tax efficiency. Profits derived from spread betting are entirely exempt from capital gains tax, providing a significant advantage over CFDs when it comes to taxation. On the flip side, CFDs offer traders the ability to offset losses against profits for tax purposes, which can be a valuable tool for effective tax planning
Stamp Duty:
Both are exempt from stamp duty, which is a tax typically applied to share purchases in traditional trading.
Commission Charges:
Spread betting generally does not involve commission charges, as the cost of trading is included in the spread. CFD trades may attract commission charges, depending on the specific market being traded.
Market Spreads:
The market spread refers to the difference between the bid and ask prices of an asset. In spread betting, the broker's charges are included in the spread, resulting in a wider spread compared to CFD trading. As a consequence, spread betting traders may incur higher spread costs. But as mentioned above the overall cost is balanced out by the added cost of commission with CFDs.
Funding Costs:
Both may incur funding costs, also known as overnight financing charges. These charges are applicable when traders hold positions overnight and are calculated based on the position size and prevailing interest rates. It's essential for traders to consider these costs, as they can significantly impact overall trading performance.
​
​
2 CFDs vs Spread Betting: Differences between how trades are placed.
Understanding how CFDs and spread bets are placed is crucial for traders looking to engage in either trading approach.
​
CFD Trading:
In CFD trading, traders buy or sell a specific number of units or contracts of the underlying asset. The profit or loss is calculated based on the difference between the opening and closing prices of the asset. This allows traders to participate directly in the price movements of the asset.
​
Spread Betting:
Spread betting involves traders placing bets on the individual price movements of the underlying asset. The trader speculates on whether the price will rise or fall, and the size of the bet is determined by the trader's desired profit or loss per point movement in the asset's price. The profit or loss is calculated based on the difference between the opening and closing prices of the bet. Unlike CFDs, spread betting does not involve ownership of the underlying asset.
3 CFD vs Spread Betting: Pros and Cons of Each Trading Approach
Both instruments have their pros and cons. Spread betting is considered tax-efficient in the UK and allows traders to speculate on a range of global instruments without commission charges. However, funding costs may be applied to positions held overnight. CFDs allow traders to offset losses against profits for tax purposes and do not attract stamp duty, but commission charges are applicable to CFDs. Both approaches offer leverage, allowing traders to deposit only a small percentage of the full value of the trade.
​
Spread Betting
Pros:
-
Tax-efficient in the UK, as profits are exempt from capital gains tax.
-
No commission charges in most cases.
-
Ability to speculate on a wide range of global instruments, including forex, indices, shares, commodities, and bonds.
-
Leverage allows traders to control larger positions with a smaller initial deposit.
Cons:
-
Funding costs may apply to positions held overnight.
-
The wider market spread can lead to higher trading costs.
​
CFD
Pros:
-
Ability to offset losses against profits for tax purposes.
-
No stamp duty on CFD trades.
-
Leverage enables traders to access larger market positions.
-
CFDs allow direct participation in the underlying asset's price movements.
Cons:
-
Commission charges may apply to certain trades.
-
Traders need to understand the underlying asset's market movements.
4 CFDs vs Spread Betting: Which is the Best Trading Strategy for You?
The choice ultimately depends on the individual trader's preferences and trading objectives. Spread betting allows traders to speculate tax-free on a wide range of global instruments, including forex, indices, shares, commodities, and bonds. Traders using spread betting decide which direction a market will move and place a bet based on the amount they want to make or lose per point movement. If the market moves in the chosen direction, traders will make a profit, and if it moves in the opposite direction, they will make a loss. CFDs, on the other hand, allow traders to buy or sell a specific amount of units or contracts and profit from market movements in the chosen direction.
​
Spread Betting Strategy:
Spread betting is ideal for traders seeking tax efficiency and flexibility. It offers the opportunity to speculate tax-free on a wide array of global instruments, allowing traders to take advantage of diverse market opportunities. Traders using spread betting decide on the direction of the market and place a bet based on the desired profit or loss per point movement. If the market moves in the chosen direction, traders will profit, and vice versa.
​
CFD Trading Strategy:
CFDs are well-suited for traders who prefer direct participation in the underlying asset's price movements. It allows traders to buy or sell specific units of the asset and profit from market movements. CFD trading is particularly useful for traders with a strong understanding of market dynamics and the ability to analyse asset trends effectively.
5 CFD vs Spread Betting: Comparing the Costs and Charges
When it comes to comparing the costs and charges, there are several factors that traders should consider, including commission charges, market spread, capital gains tax and financing costs.
​
Commission charges:
One of the main differences between CFDs and spread betting is the commission charges. CFDs are typically subject to commission charges, which can vary depending on the broker and the specific market being traded. In contrast, spread betting does not usually involve commission charges, as the cost of trading is included in the spread.
​
Market Spread:
The market spread is the difference between the bid price and ask price of an asset. In spread betting, the broker's profits come from the spread, so the spread is usually wider than in CFD trading, which can result in higher trading costs for spread betting traders.
​
Capital Gains Tax:
Profits from spread betting are currently exempt from Capital Gains Tax in the UK, while CFDs allow traders to offset losses against profits for tax purposes. However, traders should seek advice from a tax professional as tax laws may vary in different jurisdictions.
Financing costs:
Both CFDs and spread betting may be subject to financing costs, also known as overnight funding charges. These costs are incurred when traders hold positions overnight, and they are calculated based on the size of the position and the prevailing interest rates. While financing costs can be significant, they can also be positive or negative, depending on the direction of the trade and the prevailing interest rates.
​
Ultimately, the costs and charges associated with CFD and spread betting trading will depend on the specific instrument being traded. It's important for traders to compare the costs and charges of instruments to find the most cost-effective option for their trading needs.
6. CFDs vs. Spread Betting: Advantages and Risks of Leveraging
Now, let's explore the concept of leverage in more detail to further expand the content:
​
Advantages of Leveraging:
Leverage is a fundamental concept in both CFD trading and spread betting. It allows traders to control positions that are significantly larger than their initial capital investment. This can be advantageous in several ways:
​
1. Magnified Profits: By using leverage, traders can amplify their potential profits. Even a small price movement in their favor can lead to substantial gains.
​
2. Capital Efficiency: Leverage enables traders to allocate their capital more efficiently. They can diversify their portfolio and engage in multiple trades simultaneously without tying up large amounts of capital.
​
3. Access to Markets: Leverage provides access to markets that might be otherwise inaccessible due to capital constraints. It allows traders to participate in various asset classes, including commodities, indices, and currencies.
​
Risks of Leveraging:
​
While leverage offers significant advantages, it also comes with inherent risks:
​
1. Magnified Losses: Just as leverage can magnify profits, it can also amplify losses. A small adverse price movement can result in substantial losses, potentially exceeding the initial capital invested.
​
2. Margin Calls: Trading with leverage requires maintaining a margin balance. If losses exceed available margin, traders may receive margin calls, requiring them to deposit additional funds or close positions at unfavourable prices.
​
3. Increased Volatility: Leverage can make positions more sensitive to market volatility. Rapid price fluctuations can lead to unpredictable outcomes, making risk management crucial.
​
4. Psychological Stress: The pressure of managing leveraged positions can be emotionally taxing. Traders may make impulsive decisions under stress, leading to poor outcomes.
​
In summary, leverage is a powerful tool that can magnify both profits and losses in CFD trading and spread betting. It offers opportunities for capital efficiency and market access but requires careful risk management to mitigate potential downsides.
​
​
7. CFDs vs. Spread Betting: Risk Management Strategies
To complete our comprehensive exploration, let's delve into essential risk management strategies:
​
Risk Management Strategies:
Successful trading in both CFDs and spread betting hinges on effective risk management. Here are essential risk management strategies:
​
1. Stop-Loss Orders: Implement stop-loss orders to limit potential losses. These orders automatically close a position when the asset's price reaches a predetermined level, preventing further losses.
​
2. Take-Profit Orders: Use take-profit orders to secure profits at a predefined price level. These orders automatically close a position when the price reaches a specified target, ensuring that gains are realised.
​
3. Position Sizing: Determine the appropriate position size for each trade based on your risk tolerance and overall portfolio. Avoid over leveraging by ensuring that no single trade can wipe out a significant portion of your capital.
​
4. Diversification: Diversify your trading portfolio across different assets and markets to spread risk. A diversified portfolio is less susceptible to severe losses from a single adverse event.
​
5. Risk-Reward Ratio: Assess the risk-reward ratio for each trade. Ideally, aim for a positive risk-reward ratio, where the potential reward outweighs the risk. This helps ensure that winning trades can compensate for losing ones.
​
6. Trading Plan: Develop a comprehensive trading plan that includes entry and exit strategies, risk management rules, and a clear outline of your trading goals. Stick to your plan consistently.
​
7. Continuous Learning: Stay informed and continuously educate yourself about market developments, trading strategies, and risk management techniques. The more you know, the better-equipped you'll be to make informed decisions.
​
By implementing these risk management strategies, traders can navigate the challenges of leveraged trading in CFDs and spread betting while safeguarding their capital and enhancing their long-term trading success.
​
Conclusion:
In conclusion, the choice between CFDs and spread betting is a multifaceted decision that demands a thorough understanding of their differences, as well as careful consideration of tax implications, costs, and risk management strategies. While both approaches offer unique advantages, the decision ultimately depends on individual preferences, risk tolerance, and trading objectives.
To excel in the world of financial trading, traders must not only grasp the nuances of CFDs and spread betting but also employ effective risk management strategies and stay informed about market developments. With proper knowledge and discipline, traders can enhance their prospects for success in this dynamic and challenging arena.
8 CFDs vs Spread Betting: Table of key differences
9 CFD vs Spread Betting: Conclusion
In conclusion, choosing between CFDs and spread betting involves considering various factors, including tax efficiency, commission charges, market spreads, and funding costs. Each trading approach offers distinct advantages and disadvantages, catering to different trading styles and objectives.
​
Spread betting stands out for its tax efficiency and flexibility, providing an avenue for tax-free speculation across various global instruments. On the other hand, CFDs allow direct participation in underlying asset movements, making it suitable for traders with a strong market understanding.
​
Ultimately, the decision hinges on the individual trader's preferences, risk tolerance, and trading goals. To make informed choices, traders should thoroughly assess the costs and charges of both CFDs and spread betting, as well as understand the tax implications in their specific jurisdiction.
​
No matter the chosen trading approach, it is essential for traders to remain vigilant employ risk management strategies, and seek professional advice to navigate the complexities of CFDs and spread betting successfully. With proper knowledge and a disciplined approach, traders can enhance their chances of success in the exciting world of financial trading.
Award-winning
Guardian Stockbrokers reviews
​
​Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
​
I could not more highly recommend Guardian Stockbrokers, everyone has been brilliant. The attentiveness, training and technical detail provided, has enabled a fast track learning and an ability to manage the portfolio in a way that would far exceed my own capabilities. It is almost as though they own the positions themselves; via their due-diligence and proactive manner of continuous monitoring. Above and Beyond.
​
​Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
​
Professional and proactive I’m really happy that they were recommended to me.
I would recommend Guardian Stockbrokers.
​
​
​I've known Guardian Stockbrokers since their inception.
When dealing with trading, you want to work with people that are professional, personable and trustworthy.
Guardian Stockbrokers are all of the above.
I'd recommend them any day!
-
Tax laws are subject to change and depend on individual circumstances.