top of page
Futuristic Global Trading Dashboard (1).png

SPREAD BETTING | CFD TRADING

Spread Betting vs CFDs

Compare tax treatment, dealing costs, leverage and risk to understand how spread betting and CFD trading differ.

Guardian Stockbrokers relationship service, IG pricing and platform access, FCA authorisation and Best CFD Broker 2026 award
London Trading Desk with FTSE 100 Laptop.png

SPREAD BETTING | CFD COMPARISON

Understanding the Key Differences

Compare how spread betting and CFD trading work, including tax treatment, dealing costs, leverage, margin and risk.

​

Explore six key comparison points, from how each product is structured to the practical differences in pricing, funding, tax treatment and trading flexibility.

IN THE COMPARISON

01​

At a Glance

Compare the main features of both products.

02​

How They Work

Stake per point versus contracts or units.

03​

Tax Treatment

Understand the UK tax differences.

04​

Costs and Charges

Compare spreads, commissions and funding.

05​

Leverage and Risk

Understand margin, exposure and protections.

06​

Which Is More Suitable?

​Consider your trading requirements.

01

At a Glance

Comparing the main features of spread betting and CFD trading in the UK

Spread betting and Contracts for Difference (CFDs) provide two ways of trading movements in financial markets without purchasing the underlying asset. Both allow traders to take long positions when anticipating rising prices or short positions when expecting prices to fall. Both also use leverage, meaning that a relatively small margin deposit can provide exposure to a substantially larger market position, magnifying potential profits and losses.

​

Although their underlying trading principles are similar, the products differ in how positions are measured, how profits and losses are treated for tax purposes, the costs associated with certain markets and the trading facilities available. These differences are particularly relevant to UK traders considering whether spread betting, CFD trading or access to both products is appropriate for their circumstances.

Spread Betting vs CFDs at a Glance

Spread Betting

ChatGPT Image Oct 11, 2026, 08_55_40 AM-1.png

Stake per point

  • No UK Capital Gains Tax*

  • No stamp duty

  • Go long or short

  • No separate commission

  • Choose your stake currency

  • Flexible stake per point

CFD Trading

ChatGPT Image Oct 11, 2026, 08_55_41 AM-2.png

Trade contracts or units​

  • Losses may be offset against chargeable gains*

  • No stamp duty

  • Trade in underlying market currency

  • DMA available on eligible shares

  • Contract-based position sizing

CFD Trading
Spread Betting
Feature
Number of contracts or units
Stake per point of market movement
Position sizing
Indices, forex, shares and commodities
Indices, forex, shares and commodities
Market access
Go long or short
Go long or short
Trading direction
No ownership of the underlying asset
No ownership of the underlying asset
Underlying ownership
Chargeable gains generally subject to CGT
Profits generally outside CGT for UK individuals
UK Capital Gains Tax*
Allowable capital losses may offset chargeable gains
Losses generally cannot offset chargeable capital gains
Tax treatment of losses*
Generally no UK stamp duty on the derivative trade
Generally no UK stamp duty on the derivative trade
Stamp duty
Dealing spread included in quoted prices
Dealing spread included in quoted prices
Spreads: indices, FX and commodities
Separate commission normally applies alongside market spread
No separate commission; charge incorporated into the spread
Share dealing charges
Normally applies to cash CFD positions held overnight
Normally applies to Daily Funded Bets held overnight
Overnight funding
Cash CFDs generally have no fixed expiry; futures-based CFDs expire
Daily Funded Bets generally have no fixed expiry; futures-based bets expire
Contract expiry
Generally denominated in the underlying market currency
Choose an available stake currency, commonly GBP
Trading currency
Available on eligible share CFDs
Not available
Direct Market Access
Leverage limits, margin close-out and negative balance protection
Leverage limits, margin close-out and negative balance protection
Retail protections

Understanding the Practical Differences

The most immediate distinction is how a position is established. With spread betting, traders select a monetary stake for each point of price movement, making the financial effect of a change in the underlying market relatively straightforward to calculate. With CFD trading, exposure is determined by the number of contracts or units traded and the value represented by each contract. Although the dealing terminology differs, both products can provide comparable exposure to the same underlying market, and both calculate trading results using the movement between actual opening and closing prices.

​

Tax treatment represents another important difference for UK individuals. Financial spread betting profits are generally outside Capital Gains Tax, but the corresponding losses are not normally available to offset other chargeable gains. CFD trading is generally subject to the capital gains regime, meaning that gains may be taxable while allowable losses may be used against chargeable gains, subject to HMRC's rules. The treatment can differ where transactions form part of a trade, serve a commercial purpose or involve a company, so the tax position should be considered in the context of the trader's circumstances rather than viewed as an automatic advantage of either product.

​

Trading costs and available dealing facilities can also influence the choice. For most indices, currencies and commodities, IG's dealing spreads are broadly comparable across spread betting and CFDs. The distinction is more noticeable when trading individual shares, where spread betting incorporates the provider's dealing charge into the quotation, while share CFD transactions generally involve a separate commission. Both products may also incur financing charges when certain positions remain open overnight, and CFDs provide access to Direct Market Access facilities on eligible shares.

​

Despite these differences, neither product reduces the fundamental risks associated with leveraged trading. Profits and losses are determined by the full exposure of a position rather than the margin initially deposited. UK retail clients benefit from regulatory leverage limits, margin close-out requirements and account-level negative balance protection, but these safeguards do not prevent substantial losses, including the potential loss of all funds held in the trading account. Professional clients do not receive the same protections.

​

The appropriate product therefore depends on more than the potential tax treatment or the way a trade is quoted. Traders should consider the markets they intend to access, their anticipated holding periods, the costs of their particular trading activity, their financial circumstances and the facilities they require.

​

Having established the principal differences between spread betting and CFDs, the next stage is to examine how each product works in practice, including the way positions are opened, measured and closed.

02

How They Work

Understanding how spread betting stakes and CFD contracts determine market exposure and trading results

Although spread betting and CFD trading use different methods of measuring positions, the underlying trading process is remarkably similar. Both allow traders to speculate on movements in financial markets without purchasing the underlying asset, and both calculate profits and losses according to the difference between the opening and closing dealing prices.

The principal distinction is how the size of a position is expressed. Spread betting uses a monetary stake for each point of market movement, while CFD trading uses a specified number of contracts or units, each representing a particular amount of underlying market exposure. Understanding how these measurements translate into financial risk is essential when comparing the two products.

​

​

How a Spread Bet Is Structured

When placing a spread bet, the trader selects a market, chooses whether to buy or sell and specifies a monetary stake per point. The stake determines how much the position gains or loses for every point the market moves.

​

For example, a trader expecting the FTSE 100 to rise might open a long spread bet at £10 per point. If the index subsequently moves 50 points in the trader's favour, measured between the actual opening and closing dealing prices, the position generates a £500 trading profit before any additional charges or adjustments. An equivalent adverse movement produces a £500 trading loss.

​

This method allows the trader to express the financial size of a position directly as an amount per point, without needing to calculate the number of underlying contracts required. The available stake currency and minimum dealing size depend on the market and the provider's dealing conditions.

​

The amount deposited as margin is separate from the stake per point. Margin represents the funds required to open and maintain the leveraged position, whereas the stake determines the financial effect of market movements.

​

​

How a CFD Position Is Structured

A Contract for Difference is an agreement to exchange the difference in value of a financial instrument between the opening and closing of a position. Rather than selecting a monetary stake per point, the trader chooses the number of contracts or units to buy or sell.

​

The financial value of each contract depends on the market being traded. For example, IG's standard FTSE 100 CFD contract is worth £10 for every one-point movement in the index, while its mini contract is worth £2 per point. Other indices, currencies and commodities have their own contract specifications, which should be checked before entering a position.

​

CFD trading in individual shares is generally measured differently from trading indices. A share CFD normally represents one underlying share, meaning that a position in 100 CFDs provides exposure equivalent to the price movement of 100 shares, without providing ownership of those shares.

​

As with spread betting, CFD positions are leveraged and require margin rather than payment of the full underlying market value. The number of contracts or units determines the exposure, while the margin requirement determines the funds that must be maintained to support the position.

​

​

Comparing the Same FTSE 100 Trade

Consider two traders expecting the FTSE 100 to rise. Both want equivalent financial exposure and intend to close their positions following the same market movement.

​

For illustration, assume the FTSE 100 is quoted at a Buy price of 10,657.5 and both traders subsequently close at a Sell price of 10,707.5.

​

Spread Betting

The first trader opens a long spread bet at £10 per point.

A favourable movement of 50 points produces:

50 points × £10 = £500 trading profit.

​

CFD Trading

The second trader buys one standard FTSE 100 CFD contract, which represents £10 per index point.

The same favourable movement produces:

50 points × £10 = £500 trading profit.

​

If the market instead moved 50 points against both positions, each would produce a £500 trading loss before additional applicable charges or adjustments.

​

These are illustrative dealing prices rather than historical quotations. The calculations use the actual opening Buy and closing Sell prices, so the dealing spread is already reflected in the result and should not be deducted a second time.

This comparison demonstrates that the two products can provide equivalent financial exposure and produce the same trading result when their effective value per point is identical. The different methods of measuring position size do not, in themselves, make either product less risky. Differences in transaction costs, financing and currency conversion may affect the final account result, which we examine in Section 04.

​

​

Opening and Closing Positions on the Platform

Guardian clients can access both spread betting and CFD trading through IG's trading facilities, subject to the account and markets available to them. The dealing process is similar for both products, with the trader selecting a financial instrument, reviewing the quoted Buy and Sell prices and entering the required position size.

​

A Buy instruction establishes a long position, anticipating rising prices, while a Sell instruction establishes a short position, anticipating falling prices. To close an existing position, the trader deals in the opposite direction, using the available closing price. The difference between the actual opening and closing execution prices determines the trading result, taking account of the stake or contract value.

​

Before submitting an instruction, traders should review the position size, margin requirement and any attached stop-loss or limit orders. The IG platform provides information about the proposed trade and the account's available funds, allowing the trader to assess the financial exposure before confirming the position.

​

Both spread betting and CFD trading allow positions to be managed through the platform, including monitoring unrealised profits and losses, adjusting relevant orders and closing positions in full or in part, subject to dealing conditions. However, the available contract sizes, order facilities and pricing arrangements can differ between markets.

The practical distinction is therefore not the ability to speculate on rising or falling prices, but how each product represents the position and how that exposure is calculated and managed.

​

​

Understanding the Financial Exposure

Whether using a spread betting stake or CFD contracts, traders should establish the financial value of each point of movement before opening a position. A CFD contract representing £10 per point creates the same sensitivity to index movements as a £10-per-point spread bet on the same market, assuming equivalent dealing prices and exposure.

​

The amount of margin required does not represent the maximum potential loss on an individual trade. Adverse price movements can produce losses greater than the initial margin committed, and the combined exposure of several positions may substantially increase the financial risk to the account.

​

Traders should also recognise that contract specifications vary between financial instruments. A single contract in one market may represent considerably greater exposure than a contract in another, making it important to assess the actual monetary risk rather than relying on the number of contracts alone.

​

Spread betting and CFD trading offer different ways of measuring exposure to the same underlying markets. Having established how positions are structured and trading results calculated, the next stage is to examine how the UK tax treatment of the two products differs.

03

Tax Treatment

Understanding the UK tax treatment of spread betting profits, CFD gains, trading losses and stamp duty

Tax treatment is one of the most significant differences between financial spread betting and CFD trading for UK individuals. Although both products provide leveraged exposure to movements in financial markets, they are treated differently under UK tax legislation, particularly in relation to Capital Gains Tax and the availability of relief for trading losses.

​

For many UK residents, profits from financial spread betting are generally outside the scope of Capital Gains Tax, while gains arising from CFD trading will normally fall within the capital gains regime. However, the distinction is not simply that one product is tax-free and the other taxable. The ability to offset allowable losses, the purpose of the transactions and the trader's individual circumstances can all influence the overall tax position.

​

​

Spread Betting and Capital Gains Tax

For UK individuals placing financial spread bets as speculative wagers, profits are generally exempt from Capital Gains Tax. HMRC treats these transactions as betting arrangements rather than the acquisition and disposal of chargeable assets, meaning that gains and losses from ordinary financial spread betting do not normally enter the Capital Gains Tax calculation.

​

This can be an important consideration for individuals who trade regularly or who already have chargeable gains arising from other investments. For example, if a trader makes a £5,000 profit from a conventional financial spread bet, that profit would ordinarily fall outside the scope of Capital Gains Tax, regardless of whether the trader has realised gains from share investments during the same tax year.

​

However, this treatment has a corresponding disadvantage. Because spread betting profits are generally outside the capital gains regime, losses are not normally available to offset gains arising from shares, property or other chargeable investments. A trader who loses £5,000 through financial spread betting cannot ordinarily use that loss to reduce their Capital Gains Tax liability elsewhere.

​

The usual tax treatment also depends on the nature and purpose of the transaction. Spread bets undertaken for commercial purposes, such as hedging exposures arising within an existing business, may be treated differently. The normal position for an individual placing speculative spread bets should therefore not be assumed to apply automatically to every transaction or trading arrangement.

​

​

CFD Trading and Capital Gains Tax

For UK individuals, profits and losses arising from retail CFD trading are generally subject to Capital Gains Tax rules rather than the treatment applied to ordinary financial spread bets.

​

A CFD represents a contractual arrangement to exchange the difference in value of an underlying financial instrument between the opening and closing of a position. Although the trader does not own the underlying shares, index or other asset, the financial outcome of the contract will normally be taken into account when calculating chargeable gains or allowable capital losses.

​

For example, a trader who realises a £5,000 gain from CFD trading would generally include that gain within their Capital Gains Tax calculations for the relevant tax year. Whether any tax is payable depends on their overall capital gains position, available exemptions, allowable losses and applicable tax rates.

​

The treatment of losses is an important distinction. Where a CFD produces an allowable capital loss, that loss can generally be offset against chargeable gains, subject to the relevant tax rules. Unused allowable capital losses may also be carried forward and used against gains in future tax years, provided the applicable reporting and claim requirements are satisfied.

​

This does not mean CFD trading losses can ordinarily be deducted from employment income, pensions or other taxable income. Relief under the capital gains regime is generally restricted to chargeable capital gains, and losses must meet HMRC's requirements to qualify.

​

CFD calculations may also include relevant transaction costs and adjustments. Depending on the contract and circumstances, commission, financing entries and payments equivalent to dividends may form part of the overall capital gains computation rather than being treated as ordinary investment income or dividend payments.

​

​

The Tax Impact of a £100,000 Trading Profit and Allowable Losses

The financial significance of the different tax treatments becomes clearer when considering substantial trading profits or losses. Although spread betting and CFD trading can provide equivalent market exposure, the amount a trader retains following a profitable year, or the tax relief potentially available following losses, can differ considerably.​​​​

Illustrative Comparison: £100,000 Trading Profit

The tax treatment becomes clearer when comparing the same £100,000 trading profit under spread betting and CFD trading, using 2026/27 UK tax assumptions.

Tax Comparison_ Spread Betting vs CFDs.png

Under these assumptions, the spread betting client retains the full £100,000 profit, while the CFD trader retains £76,720 after Capital Gains Tax. This represents a potential tax difference of £23,280 in favour of spread betting.

Potential Reduction in CFD Capital Gains Tax

A CFD trader may be able to reduce their Capital Gains Tax liability if they have allowable capital losses from other investments or previous trading activity. The following illustration shows how these losses could affect the tax payable on a £100,000 CFD trading profit.

CFD Capital Gains Tax Reduction Guide.png

The availability of capital loss relief depends on the individual's wider tax circumstances. Although sufficient allowable losses could eliminate the Capital Gains Tax liability, those losses still represent real financial losses. A reduction in tax does not mean the trader has achieved the same overall financial return as someone who retained the full profit without requiring any offsets.

What These Examples Demonstrate

For a UK individual generating substantial trading profits, spread betting may offer a significant tax advantage because ordinary financial spread betting gains are generally outside Capital Gains Tax. CFD trading offers a different potential benefit through the ability to offset qualifying losses against chargeable gains, including gains arising from other investments.

However, traders cannot know in advance whether their positions will produce profits or losses, and the possibility of tax relief should never be a reason to accept greater financial exposure. The appropriate choice must also reflect trading costs, available markets, contract arrangements and the individual's financial circumstances.

​

These examples use illustrative 2026/27 UK tax assumptions, including a 24% Capital Gains Tax rate and the £3,000 annual exempt amount. Actual liabilities and reliefs depend on individual circumstances and the applicable tax legislation.

​

​

Stamp Duty and Underlying Ownership

Both spread betting and CFD trading generally avoid UK Stamp Duty and Stamp Duty Reserve Tax on the derivative transaction because neither involves the trader purchasing the underlying shares.

​

This differs from conventional share dealing, where the acquisition of certain UK shares may attract stamp duty or Stamp Duty Reserve Tax, normally at 0.5% of the purchase consideration.

​

With spread betting, the trader enters into a financial wager based on price movements, while a CFD represents a contract whose value is derived from changes in the underlying instrument. In neither case does the position itself provide ownership of the underlying shares, shareholder voting rights or ordinary shareholding dividends.

​

Share-based spread bets and CFDs may instead involve cash adjustments reflecting dividend events. These adjustments should not be confused with receiving dividends as a shareholder, and their tax treatment must be considered within the relevant product arrangements.

​

The absence of stamp duty is therefore a feature shared by both derivatives rather than an advantage exclusive to either spread betting or CFD trading.

​

​

When Tax Treatment May Differ

The comparisons throughout this guide principally concern UK-resident individuals trading on their own account. Different rules can apply where derivatives are held by companies, used for business purposes or entered into as part of commercial hedging arrangements.

​

For companies, financial spread bets and CFDs may fall within the Corporation Tax derivative contracts regime, rather than the treatment applicable to individual speculative spread betting. Similarly, where an individual enters into a derivative transaction for the purposes of an existing trade, the tax consequences may differ from those of personal investment or speculative activity.

Tax residence is another important consideration. A trader who lives outside the UK, or whose residence status changes, should not assume that the UK treatment described here applies in the same way in another jurisdiction.

​

These distinctions make it important to consider the purpose of the transaction and the trader's overall financial circumstances, particularly where substantial gains, losses or business-related positions are involved.

​

​

Considering Tax Alongside Trading Requirements

While tax treatment is an important consideration, it should not be the sole reason for choosing between spread betting and CFD trading.

​

A product that offers favourable tax treatment may still be unsuitable because of its available markets, position-sizing

arrangements, trading costs or the financial exposure involved. Equally, the potential availability of capital loss relief on CFDs does not make them inherently less risky than spread betting.

​

Traders should assess the tax consequences alongside their intended markets, trading frequency, expected holding periods and the facilities available through each product. Where individual tax circumstances are complex, appropriate independent tax advice should be obtained rather than relying on general product comparisons.

​

The main UK tax distinction is that ordinary financial spread betting profits are generally outside Capital Gains Tax, whereas CFD gains and allowable losses normally fall within the capital gains regime. Having established these differences, the next stage is to compare the dealing costs, commissions and financing arrangements associated with each product.

​

Important Tax Information

The tax information provided is for general guidance only and does not constitute personal tax advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances, tax residence and applicable legislation, which may change.

​

Guardian Stockbrokers does not provide tax advice. You should seek advice from a suitably qualified, independent tax adviser regarding your individual circumstances before making trading decisions based on potential tax advantages.

04

Costs and Charges

Comparing spreads, commissions, overnight funding and the additional costs of spread betting and CFD trading

The costs associated with spread betting and CFD trading can have a significant effect on trading results, particularly for clients who trade frequently, maintain larger positions or hold trades open for extended periods. Although both products provide access to many of the same financial markets, their charging structures can differ depending on the underlying instrument, the position size and how long a trade remains open.

​

For indices, foreign exchange and commodities, spread betting and CFD trading generally involve similar spread-based dealing charges. The principal distinction arises when trading individual shares, where spread betting incorporates the dealing charge into the quoted spread, while share CFDs normally attract a separate commission. Both products can also incur overnight funding, currency conversion and other charges. Guardian clients access IG's trading facilities, with the applicable charges determined by IG rather than Guardian.

​

​

Understanding the Dealing Spread

The dealing spread is the difference between the quoted Buy and Sell prices of a financial instrument. When opening a long position, a trader buys at the higher price, while a short position is opened at the lower price. The spread therefore represents an immediate trading cost, reflected in the difference between the execution price and the price at which the position could be closed if market quotations remained unchanged.

​

For most index, foreign exchange and commodity markets, IG incorporates its dealing charge into the quoted spread for both spread betting and CFD trading. This means there is generally no separate dealing commission on these markets. However, spreads vary according to market conditions and may widen during periods of volatility, around major economic announcements or when liquidity is reduced.

​

Worked Example 1: FTSE 100 Dealing Spread

Consider a trader opening a £10-per-point position in the FTSE 100, or an equivalent CFD position with a value of £10 per index point.

WORKED EXAMPLE 1: FTSE 100 DEALING SPREAD

Sell price
Buy price
Dealing spread
Position value per point


Initial spread-related cost

10,000
10,002
2 points
£10


£20

The two-point spread represents an immediate £20 difference between the opening and available closing prices, assuming the market quotation remains unchanged. Both products would have the same spread-related cost if their effective value per point and quoted dealing prices were identical.

​

The spread is already reflected in the actual opening and closing prices, so it should not be deducted a second time when calculating the final trading result.

​

​

Share Trading: Spread Betting Versus CFD Commission

The difference in charging structures becomes more apparent when trading individual company shares. IG generally incorporates the dealing charge for a share spread bet into its Buy and Sell quotations, meaning there is no separate dealing commission. With share CFDs, the trader normally deals against prices derived from the underlying share market and pays a separate commission when opening and closing the position.

​

IG's published online commission for UK FTSE 350 share CFDs is currently 0.10% of the transaction value per side, subject to a £10 minimum. Different commission arrangements apply to shares outside the FTSE 350 and to international markets, including US shares, where commission is normally calculated per share. The total dealing cost must therefore be assessed using the relevant market's actual charging structure.

​

​

Worked Example 2: £20,000 UK Share CFD Position

A trader opens a £20,000 CFD position in an eligible FTSE 350 company and subsequently closes the position at the same underlying value.

WORKED EXAMPLE 2: £20,000 UK SHARE CFD

Position value
Opening commission at 0.10%
Closing commission at 0.10%



Total dealing commission

£20,000
£20
£20



£40

The £40 represents commission on opening and closing the CFD position. The underlying share's market spread and any applicable overnight funding or other charges are additional.

​

An equivalent share spread bet would not normally attract a separate commission, but IG's dealing charge would instead be incorporated into the quoted spread. Consequently, neither product can automatically be considered cheaper without comparing the actual opening and closing prices, the commission payable and the intended position size.

This distinction can be particularly relevant to active share traders. Minimum commission charges may have a greater proportional impact on smaller CFD positions, while spread-based pricing can affect trading costs differently as position sizes increase.

​

​

Overnight Funding and Holding Costs

Both spread betting and CFD trading are leveraged products, allowing traders to control a financial position with an initial margin deposit that is smaller than the full market exposure. Where a Daily Funded Bet or cash CFD remains open through IG's overnight funding cut-off, normally 10pm UK time, a financing adjustment generally applies. The calculation depends on the underlying market, position value, relevant interest rates and the applicable IG administration charge.

​

Importantly, overnight funding is calculated by reference to the relevant market exposure, not simply the margin deposited to open the trade. A trader controlling £100,000 of market exposure may therefore incur funding costs based on that larger position, even though the initial margin requirement is substantially lower. For positions held over several weeks, accumulated funding costs can materially affect the final trading result.

​

​

Worked Example 3: Illustrative Overnight Funding

Consider a long leveraged index position with £100,000 of market exposure. For this simplified illustration, assume the applicable total annualised financing rate is 6%.

WORKED EXAMPLE 3: ILLUSTRATIVE OVERNIGHT FUNDING

Market exposure
Assumed annualised funding rate
Annualised funding amount



Approximate daily funding cost

£100,000
6%
£6,000



£16.44

This example illustrates how an annualised financing rate translates into a daily cost. The 6% figure is hypothetical and is not a quotation of IG's current funding rate. Actual charges depend on IG's market-specific calculations, prevailing rates, position direction and any relevant adjustments.

​

Funding arrangements also differ between long and short positions. Depending on the market and applicable interest rates, short positions may receive a financing credit or incur a charge. Traders should also account for weekend funding conventions, including occasions when multiple days of financing are applied together.

​

​

Cash Positions Versus Futures-Based Contracts

The choice between a cash position and a futures-based contract can have as much influence on trading costs as the decision between spread betting and CFDs. Daily Funded Bets and cash CFDs generally offer tighter initial dealing spreads but are subject to ongoing funding adjustments when held overnight. Futures-based spread bets and CFDs are priced differently, with financing considerations reflected in the contract price or spread rather than normally being charged as separate daily overnight funding.

For a short-term trade, the tighter spread on a cash market may be more attractive because the position is unlikely to accumulate substantial financing costs. For a position intended to remain open over several weeks or months, a futures-based contract may warrant consideration. However, futures can have wider spreads, fixed expiry dates and additional costs associated with closing or rolling positions, so the absence of a separate daily funding charge does not necessarily mean that they are cheaper.

​

The relevant comparison is the total expected cost over the intended holding period. Traders should consider the initial spread, accumulated financing, contract expiry and any costs associated with maintaining the position beyond the original contract date.

​

​

Currency Conversion and International Markets

Currency conversion is another consideration for UK clients trading international financial markets. Spread betting generally allows the trader to select an available stake currency, commonly sterling, whereas CFD positions are generally denominated in the currency of the underlying instrument. For example, a CFD position in a US company will normally produce profits, losses and applicable charges in US dollars.

​

Where a transaction's currency differs from the trading account's base currency, conversion charges may apply when profits, losses, commissions or financing adjustments are converted. IG's conversion arrangements depend on the account settings and the particular transaction, making it important to consider the currency in which an exposure is held and how the resulting financial adjustments will be processed.

​

For traders dealing regularly in US or European shares, currency conversion can become a meaningful part of the overall cost. A comparison based solely on the quoted dealing spread or commission may therefore overlook charges that affect the final sterling result.

​

​

Other Charges to Consider

Certain transactions involve additional costs beyond the dealing spread, commission and overnight funding. These are not necessarily applicable to every market or trade, but they should be understood before opening a position.

​

Short Share Borrowing Charges: Short positions in individual shares may attract stock-borrowing fees, which can vary according to the underlying company's share availability. Borrowing charges may change, sometimes at short notice, and can affect the cost or availability of maintaining a short position.

​

Guaranteed Stop-Loss Orders: Where available, guaranteed stops provide protection against execution beyond the specified stop level, subject to the relevant terms. IG charges a premium if the guaranteed stop is triggered. Standard stop-loss orders do not provide the same execution guarantee.

​

Dividend Adjustments: Positions involving shares or stock indices may receive or incur cash adjustments when relevant dividends become payable. These adjustments depend on the instrument and whether the trader holds a long or short position, and they can affect the final account result.

​

Market Data and Additional Services: Live exchange data, certain Direct Market Access facilities and specialist charting services may involve additional charges. These are particularly relevant to active traders using advanced dealing facilities.

​

​

Comparing the Total Cost of Trading

The most meaningful comparison between spread betting and CFD trading is the total cost of establishing, maintaining and closing an equivalent position. This means considering the dealing spread, applicable commission, overnight funding, currency conversion and any additional adjustments rather than concentrating on an individual charge.

​

For a trader opening and closing a short-term FTSE 100 position, the dealing costs of the two products may be broadly similar. For an active share trader, the difference between spread-based pricing and separate CFD commission can be more relevant. Where positions are held for longer periods, accumulated financing costs may become the principal consideration, potentially making the choice between cash and futures-based contracts especially important.

​

Guardian clients have access to IG's trading facilities alongside the relationship and direct access provided by Guardian's experienced stockbroking team. As charges are determined by IG and can change, clients should review the current contract details and applicable pricing before placing a trade.

​

Spread betting and CFD trading can provide similar market exposure, but the cost of that exposure depends on the instrument traded, the position size and the intended holding period. Understanding the complete charging structure is essential when assessing the suitability of either product. Having considered trading costs, the next stage is to examine leverage, margin requirements and the financial risks associated with both products.

​

​For full details of the applicable dealing spreads, commissions, overnight funding and other charges, please refer to IG's current costs and charges

05

Leverage and Risk

Understanding margin requirements, leveraged exposure, margin close-out and the protections available to Retail and Professional clients

Leverage is one of the defining characteristics of both spread betting and CFD trading. It allows traders to take positions in financial markets without committing the full underlying value of the exposure. Instead, a proportion of the position's value is required as an initial margin deposit, with profits and losses calculated on the full financial exposure rather than the amount deposited.

​

Although leverage can increase the potential return relative to the margin committed, it magnifies losses in exactly the same way. A relatively small movement in the underlying market can therefore produce a substantial change in the value of a trading position. These risks apply equally to spread betting and CFDs where the effective market exposure is identical, making position sizing, available account funds and risk management more important than the choice of product itself.

​

​

Understanding Leverage and Margin

Leverage describes the relationship between the full value of a trading position and the margin required to open it. For example, a position with 20:1 leverage requires an initial margin equivalent to 5% of its underlying market exposure. A trader controlling a £100,000 position would therefore need £5,000 in initial margin, rather than the full £100,000.

​

The margin deposit is not a payment for the underlying asset, nor does it represent the maximum amount that can be lost on a particular trade. It is the amount required to establish and maintain the leveraged position, while the financial outcome depends on the movement in the underlying market and the trader's position size.

​

For UK Retail clients, maximum leverage is restricted according to the financial instrument being traded. Major foreign exchange pairs may be available at up to 30:1 leverage, major stock indices such as the FTSE 100 at up to 20:1, and individual shares at up to 5:1. Different limits apply to other markets, and the margin required may be higher depending on the instrument, aggregate exposure and prevailing conditions.

​

IG generally applies equivalent Retail margin requirements to comparable spread betting and CFD positions. Consequently, a trader taking the same FTSE 100 exposure through either product would normally require a similar initial margin, subject to the relevant contract specifications and any additional margin requirements.

Worked Example 1: FTSE 100 Leverage and Market Exposure
Consider a trader opening a £10-per-point FTSE 100 spread bet when the index is trading at an illustrative level of 10,000. An equivalent position could be established through one standard FTSE 100 CFD contract, also representing £10 for each index point.
 

Illustrative FTSE 100 level
Position value per point
Total market exposure
Retail margin requirement

Initial margin required

10,000
£10
£100,000
5%

£5,000

Both positions provide exposure equivalent to £100,000 of the underlying index, while requiring an initial margin deposit of £5,000 under these assumptions.

​

If the FTSE 100 rises by 100 points, the position generates a £1,000 trading profit. If the index falls by 100 points, it produces a £1,000 trading loss, assuming a long position and equivalent execution prices.

Market movement

Trading result

FTSE 100 rises 100 points
FTSE 100 falls 100 points
FTSE 100 falls 250 points

+£1,000
−£1,000
−£2,500

A movement of just 1% in the underlying index produces a £1,000 change in the position's value, equivalent to 20% of the original £5,000 margin deposit.

​

This illustrates the effect of leverage. The trader's financial exposure is determined by the £10-per-point position, not the £5,000 margin committed. The same calculations apply to an equivalent CFD position, before considering applicable dealing costs, financing and other adjustments.

​

​

Margin Requirements and Available Account Funds

Initial margin represents the minimum amount required to establish a position, but maintaining sufficient account funds is an ongoing responsibility. As market prices change, unrealised profits and losses affect the account's equity, while the margin required to support open positions may also change.

​

If a position moves against the trader, the reduction in account equity can bring the account closer to its required margin level. Where available equity becomes insufficient, the account may enter margin call, requiring the trader to consider reducing exposure, depositing additional funds or closing positions. The broker may also close positions automatically under its applicable margin arrangements.

​

Margin requirements are not necessarily fixed for the lifetime of a trade. IG uses tiered margin arrangements for certain markets and may increase requirements where exposure becomes larger, volatility increases or market conditions change. Traders holding multiple positions should therefore consider their combined margin requirements rather than calculating risk solely on individual trades.

​

Maintaining only the minimum margin required to open a position leaves limited room for adverse market movements. A trader may have enough funds to establish a leveraged position but insufficient available equity to withstand normal market fluctuations without the risk of forced closure.

​

​

Retail Margin Close-Out Protection

UK regulatory rules require providers of Retail spread betting and CFD accounts to apply margin close-out protection. Under these requirements, positions must be closed when account equity falls below 50% of the margin required to maintain the relevant open positions, as soon as market conditions allow.

​

This protection operates at account level rather than providing a guaranteed stop-loss price for each individual trade. The relevant calculation takes account of the equity and margin requirements of the account's open positions, meaning that losses across several markets can contribute to a margin close-out event.

Worked Example 2: The 50% Margin Close-Out Rule
Consider a Retail client who has £5,000 in account equity and opens a leveraged position requiring £5,000 in margin. For simplicity, assume the margin requirement remains unchanged and there are no other positions, funding charges or deposits.

Description

Amount

Starting account equity
Margin required
Margin close-out threshold

Illustrative equity threshold

£5,000
£5,000
50%

£2,500

If losses reduce account equity below £2,500, the regulatory margin close-out requirement is triggered. IG may then close the relevant position to reduce the account's exposure.

​

However, the £2,500 figure is not a guaranteed closing balance. The actual close-out level can change if margin requirements change, while rapid market movements, gaps and execution conditions can affect the eventual closing price. IG may also close positions under its risk management arrangements before this threshold is reached.

​

A margin close-out mechanism is therefore a protective measure rather than a substitute for setting an appropriate position size, maintaining sufficient funds and managing risk independently.

​

​

Negative Balance Protection for Retail Clients

Another important regulatory safeguard is negative balance protection, which applies to UK Retail spread betting and CFD accounts.

​

This protection means that a Retail client cannot lose more than the total funds in the relevant trading account as a result of leveraged positions. If an extreme market movement causes the account balance to become negative, IG is required to restore the balance to zero in accordance with the applicable Retail protection rules.

​

Negative balance protection is particularly relevant during market gaps or exceptional volatility, when prices may move beyond expected levels before a position can be closed. It protects against a debt arising from a negative balance on the relevant Retail account, but it does not prevent the client from losing all the funds held within that account.

​

It is also important to distinguish the account balance from the initial margin on an individual position. A trader who opens a position requiring £1,000 in margin may lose more than that £1,000 if additional funds are available in the account. Negative balance protection applies at account level, not separately to each position's original margin deposit.

​

These Retail protections apply to both spread betting and CFD trading. Neither product offers an inherent advantage over the other in terms of the regulatory protection against negative account balances.

​

​

Stop-Loss Orders and Managing Trading Risk

Stop-loss orders allow traders to specify a price at which a position should be closed if the market moves against them. They can help establish the intended financial risk of a trade before entry and provide a practical method of managing positions without continuously monitoring every market movement.

​

However, a standard stop-loss order does not guarantee execution at the requested price. If the underlying market moves rapidly or gaps beyond the stop level, the position may be closed at the next available dealing price, producing a larger loss than originally anticipated.

Worked Example 3: Stop-Loss Execution and Slippage
Consider a trader holding a long FTSE 100 position worth £10 per point, with an intended stop-loss 50 points below the opening price.

Description

Amount

Position value per point
Intended stop distance
Intended trading loss
Actual adverse movement on execution

Actual trading loss

£10
50 points
£500
80 points

£800

In this illustration, the market moves beyond the intended stop level before the order can be executed. The additional 30 points of adverse movement increase the loss by £300.

​

A guaranteed stop-loss order, where available, can protect against execution beyond the specified stop level, subject to the applicable terms. IG charges a premium if the guaranteed stop is triggered, making it important to consider the additional cost alongside the protection provided.

​

Stop-loss orders, position limits and adequate account funds should be considered together. None removes the underlying financial risks of leveraged trading, and traders should establish the amount they are prepared to lose before opening a position.

 

 

Professional Clients: Higher Leverage and Different Protections

Clients classified as Elective Professional may qualify for substantially lower margin requirements than Retail clients, allowing them to take equivalent positions with less initial margin. This can provide greater flexibility for experienced traders who actively manage larger exposures or require more efficient use of trading capital.

​

However, lower margin requirements do not reduce the financial risk of the underlying position. A £100,000 market exposure produces the same monetary profit or loss for a given market movement, whether the trader is required to deposit £5,000 in Retail margin or a smaller amount under Professional margin arrangements. Lower initial margin can allow a client to take larger positions relative to available capital, increasing the potential for substantial losses.

​

The regulatory protections available to Professional clients also differ. In particular, Professional clients do not benefit from the Retail negative balance protection requirement and may therefore incur losses exceeding the funds held in their trading accounts. Retail leverage restrictions and the mandatory Retail 50% margin close-out protection no longer apply in the same way, although IG operates its own margin and close-out arrangements for Professional accounts.

​

Professional classification is not automatic. Clients must satisfy the applicable eligibility requirements, including at least two of the three relevant quantitative criteria, together with Guardian's assessment of their expertise, experience and knowledge. Meeting the quantitative criteria alone does not guarantee that Professional status will be granted.

​

Experienced traders considering Professional classification should therefore assess the consequences of reduced regulatory protections alongside any potential benefits of lower margins and additional trading facilities.​​

For more information about eligibility, margin arrangements and the protections that change, see our

Comparing Risk Between Spread Betting and CFDs

When spread betting and CFD positions provide equivalent financial exposure to the same underlying market, their potential profits and losses are fundamentally similar. A £10-per-point spread bet and a CFD position worth £10 per point will generally respond in the same monetary way to a given index movement, assuming equivalent execution prices.

​

The principal factors determining risk are therefore the size of the position, the volatility of the underlying market, the use of leverage and the trader's approach to managing exposure. Product-specific contract arrangements, dealing conditions, financing costs and currency movements may affect the final result, but neither spread betting nor CFD trading should be regarded as inherently safer simply because positions are expressed differently.

​

For Retail clients, the regulatory framework provides comparable leverage restrictions, margin close-out protection and negative balance protection across both products. Professional clients may have access to different margin arrangements, but must also recognise the increased responsibilities and financial risks associated with reduced Retail protections.

​

Ultimately, successful risk management begins with understanding the full market exposure before entering a trade, maintaining adequate account funds and establishing how much can be lost if the market moves adversely. Margin determines the capital required to support a position; it does not determine the financial risk the trader has chosen to accept.

​

Spread betting and CFD trading use the same fundamental principles of leverage and market exposure, with comparable risks and Retail regulatory protections. The more relevant considerations are the trader's objectives, preferred markets, trading costs, tax circumstances and account classification. Having examined these differences, the final section considers which product may be more suitable for different trading requirements.

06

Which Is More Suitable?

Choosing between spread betting and CFDs based on your trading objectives, preferred markets, tax circumstances and dealing requirements

There is no single answer to whether spread betting or CFD trading is more suitable. Both products allow traders to take positions in rising and falling markets without owning the underlying asset, and both involve leverage, margin requirements and the risk of substantial financial losses. Where the effective market exposure is identical, their underlying trading risks are broadly comparable.

​

The decision therefore depends on more than personal preference or the perceived advantages of one product. A trader's tax circumstances, preferred financial markets, trading frequency, expected holding periods and requirements for particular dealing facilities can all influence the choice. For some UK clients, spread betting may provide the most straightforward approach, while others may find CFD trading more appropriate. Experienced traders may also benefit from having access to both products for different purposes.

​

​

When Spread Betting May Be More Suitable

Spread betting may appeal to UK individuals who want to take speculative positions in financial markets while benefiting from the usual exemption from Capital Gains Tax on profits. As demonstrated in Section 03, this can produce a substantial financial difference where meaningful trading profits are realised and the equivalent CFD gains would otherwise be taxable. However, the tax advantage must be considered alongside the fact that spread betting losses generally cannot be used to offset chargeable gains elsewhere.

​

The stake-per-point structure can also make financial exposure relatively straightforward to calculate. A trader selecting £5 or £10 per point can immediately understand the monetary effect of a given market movement, without first converting contract quantities into an equivalent value per point. The ability to select an available stake currency, commonly sterling, may also appeal to UK traders who regularly access overseas indices, currencies and commodities.

​

For clients primarily trading major indices, foreign exchange and commodities, where dealing charges are generally incorporated into the spread, spread betting can offer a practical and familiar way to access the markets. Nevertheless, favourable tax treatment and convenient position sizing do not automatically make spread betting the lowest-cost option or the most suitable product for every trading strategy.

​

​

When CFD Trading May Be More Suitable

CFD trading may be more appropriate for clients who prefer to measure positions using a specified number of contracts or underlying share units. This structure can be particularly relevant to individual share trading, where the number of CFDs generally corresponds to the quantity of shares represented by the position. It may also appeal to traders who prefer separate, identifiable dealing commissions rather than having the provider's share dealing charge incorporated into a wider quotation.

An important distinction is the availability of Direct Market Access on eligible share CFDs. This allows suitably enabled clients to interact with the underlying market's order book through IG's relevant dealing facilities, rather than relying solely on conventional over-the-counter quotations. For active share traders who require greater visibility of market depth and order execution, this may be a significant consideration that is not available through ordinary spread betting.

​

The treatment of allowable capital losses may also influence the choice. CFD gains are generally within the Capital Gains Tax regime, but qualifying losses may be available to offset chargeable gains from other investments or trading activity. This can be particularly relevant when considering positions used to manage exposure to an existing investment portfolio. However, both products can be used to hedge market risk, and the tax treatment of any loss depends on the circumstances. CFD trading should not be selected on the assumption that losses will necessarily arise or that tax relief will always be available.

​

​

How Different Trading Requirements Affect the Choice

​

A UK Trader Focusing on Major Stock Indices

Consider an individual who primarily trades the FTSE 100, Wall Street and Germany 40, taking short-term positions based on market developments and economic announcements. Both spread betting and CFDs can provide comparable exposure to these markets, with similar underlying risks and broadly similar dealing arrangements. Spread betting may be attractive because of its stake-per-point structure and the usual UK Capital Gains Tax treatment, although position size, execution conditions and trading costs remain important.

​

An Active Trader Dealing in UK and US Shares

A trader dealing regularly in individual shares may place greater importance on execution facilities, market depth, commission structures and currency arrangements. Share CFDs may be attractive where access to Direct Market Access is required or where the trader prefers to measure exposure in share units. Spread betting remains an alternative, particularly where sterling-denominated stakes and the normal tax treatment of gains are priorities. Comparing the actual costs and facilities of the intended markets is essential before choosing.

​

An Investor Managing an Existing Share Portfolio

An individual holding an investment portfolio may want to reduce market exposure temporarily without selling the underlying investments. Both spread betting and CFDs can potentially be used to establish offsetting positions, although such arrangements introduce their own costs and risks and may not provide a perfect hedge. CFD trading may merit particular consideration where qualifying losses could be relevant to the investor's wider capital gains position, but this requires careful assessment of the specific transactions and independent tax advice where appropriate.

​

These examples demonstrate why the characteristics of the trader and the intended use of the product matter more than simply identifying which product has the greatest number of apparent advantages.

​

When Access to Both Products May Be Useful

Choosing between spread betting and CFD trading does not necessarily mean committing exclusively to one product. IG provides access to both account types, subject to the relevant account opening requirements, allowing clients to consider the different arrangements available for particular markets and trading activities.

​

For example, an experienced UK trader might prefer spread betting when trading major stock indices using sterling-denominated stakes, while maintaining access to CFDs for eligible share trading or specialist dealing facilities. Another client may want the flexibility to compare the two products before entering a position, taking account of contract size, dealing charges, financing, currency exposure and tax circumstances.

​

Access to both products can therefore provide greater flexibility, but it does not justify taking additional positions or increasing overall leverage. Any positions held across different accounts must be considered together when assessing total financial exposure, available capital and the ability to withstand adverse market movements.

​

What Matters Most Before Making a Decision

Before choosing a product, traders should establish the markets they intend to trade, how frequently they expect to deal and how long positions are likely to remain open. Short-term index trading may place greater emphasis on dealing spreads and execution, while longer holding periods make financing arrangements increasingly important. Active share trading can introduce further considerations, including commission, Direct Market Access and currency conversion.

​

Tax treatment should be considered as part of the overall decision, but it cannot be assessed reliably by assuming that future trades will be profitable or loss-making. The availability of allowable losses, other chargeable gains and the trader's individual circumstances can materially affect the outcome. Neither product should be chosen solely because of a potential tax advantage.

Above all, traders must understand the financial exposure created by their positions. Spread betting and CFDs are both complex leveraged products, and neither is inherently safer when used to obtain equivalent market exposure. Retail regulatory protections apply to both products, while Professional classification involves different margin arrangements and reduced protections. The appropriate product and position size must therefore reflect the client's experience, financial resources, objectives and capacity to bear losses.

​

For someone seeking straightforward long-term ownership of shares without leverage, conventional share dealing may be more appropriate than either derivative product.

​

Making the Choice with Guardian Stockbrokers

Guardian Stockbrokers provides access to both spread betting and CFD trading through IG's established trading platform, supported by the personal service and direct access of an experienced UK stockbroker. Clients can use the platform independently while retaining the option to speak directly with Guardian about trading requirements, product mechanics, dealing facilities and the risks involved.

​

Our approach is to help clients understand the differences before they trade, rather than suggest that one product is universally better. Whether a client primarily trades indices, actively deals in shares or requires access to a wider range of markets, the objective is to establish an appropriate trading arrangement with a clear understanding of the available facilities, costs and financial exposure.

​

Guardian clients receive the applicable IG platform pricing without an additional Guardian mark-up, alongside the relationship led service of an independent FCA-authorised UK stockbroker.

​

Spread betting and CFD trading are different ways of accessing many of the same financial markets. Spread betting may offer advantages through its UK tax treatment and stake-based position sizing, while CFDs provide alternative contract arrangements, eligible share Direct Market Access and the potential use of allowable capital losses. The better choice depends on how those differences relate to your individual trading requirements, financial circumstances and understanding of risk.

IG trading platform across desktop, tablet and mobile

How to get started
Open your account in a few simple steps

1

Apply

Complete the short Guardian application.

2

Open your IG account

We will introduce you to IG to open a trading account.

3

Fund your account

Add funds securely with IG.

4

Start trading

Trade online or call your Guardian relationship manager.

Best CFD Broker 2026

Guardian Stockbrokers was named Best CFD Broker 2026 at the ADVFN International Financial Awards.

​

ADVFN-Best-CFD-Broker-2026-02.png
ADVFN Award.jpg

What our clients say
Trusted by traders across the UK

Darren Lewis

​

 

 

Professionalism, Responsiveness

​

 

Professional and proactive I’m really happy that they were recommended to me.


I would recommend Guardian Stockbrokers.

Paul Daniel

​

 

 

Professionalism, Quality,

Responsiveness, Value

​

I could not more highly recommend Guardian Stockbrokers, everyone has been brilliant. The attentiveness, training and technical detail provided, has enabled a fast track learning and an ability to manage the portfolio in a way that would far exceed my own capabilities. ​

Tabrez Ahmad

​

​

 

Professionalism, Responsiveness​

 

​

​I've known Guardian Stockbrokers since their inception.

When dealing with trading, you want to work with people that are professional, personable and trustworthy.

Guardian Stockbrokers are all of the above. ​

I'd recommend them any day!

Global markets trading with Guardian Stockbrokers

Does your broker know your name?

Your new one will.

Trade global markets. Be known.

Spread Betting vs CFDs FAQs

bottom of page